d-bis/metrics
4
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
main
metrics/GOVERNANCE_METRICS_TRACKING.md
defiQUG 069f170877 Initial commit: add .gitignore and README
2026-02-09 21:51:46 -08:00

6.8 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Governance Metrics Tracking

Version: 1.0 Date: 2025-01-27 Purpose: Track governance process effectiveness and health

Metrics Overview

This document defines metrics to track the effectiveness of the canonical governance framework.

Key Metrics

1. Proposal Submission Metrics

Submission Rate

  • Metric: Number of proposals submitted per month/quarter
  • Target: Track baseline, identify trends
  • Collection: Count proposals in proposals/active/ and proposals/approved/

Proposal Types

  • Metric: Distribution by type (Constitutional, Architectural, Interface, Policy, etc.)
  • Target: Understand change patterns
  • Collection: Categorize proposals by type

2. Review Process Metrics

Average Review Time

  • Metric: Time from submission to final decision (days)
  • Target: Within timeline guidelines
    • Constitutional: 30-60 days
    • Architectural: 14-30 days
    • Interface: 14-21 days
    • Policy: 14-30 days
  • Collection: Calculate from submission date to approval/rejection date

Review Time by System

  • Metric: Time each Tier-1 system takes to provide recognition (days)
  • Target: Within review period, identify bottlenecks
  • Collection: Track recognition dates per system

Review Completion Rate

  • Metric: Percentage of proposals reviewed within deadline
  • Target: >90% on-time reviews
  • Collection: Compare actual review time to deadline

3. Approval Metrics

Approval Rate

  • Metric: Percentage of proposals approved
  • Target: Track baseline, aim for high approval of well-prepared proposals
  • Collection: Count approved vs. rejected proposals

Conditional Approval Rate

  • Metric: Percentage of proposals approved with conditions
  • Target: Track pattern, improve proposal quality if high
  • Collection: Count conditional approvals

Rejection Rate

  • Metric: Percentage of proposals rejected
  • Target: Track baseline, identify common rejection reasons
  • Collection: Count rejected proposals, categorize reasons

4. Implementation Metrics

Implementation Time

  • Metric: Time from approval to implementation completion (days)
  • Target: Track against implementation plan estimates
  • Collection: Track from approval to implementation completion

Implementation Success Rate

  • Metric: Percentage of approved proposals successfully implemented
  • Target: >95% successful implementation
  • Collection: Track implementation status

5. Compliance Metrics

Compliance Violations

  • Metric: Number of unauthorized Tier-1 changes
  • Target: Zero violations
  • Collection: Track changes without proposals (should be zero)

Compliance Checklist Completion

  • Metric: Percentage of proposals with complete compliance checklists
  • Target: 100%
  • Collection: Verify checklist completion

6. Process Health Metrics

Emergency Changes

  • Metric: Number of emergency changes per period
  • Target: Minimize, track frequency
  • Collection: Count emergency declarations

Process Exceptions

  • Metric: Number of process exceptions/bypasses
  • Target: Minimize, document all
  • Collection: Track exception requests and approvals

Dispute Resolution

  • Metric: Number of ICCC adjudications required
  • Target: Track frequency, identify common disputes
  • Collection: Count ICCC dispute submissions

Metrics Dashboard Template

Quarterly Metrics Summary

Period: Q[1-4] YYYY

Proposal Activity

  • Total Proposals Submitted: [Count]
  • Proposals Approved: [Count]
  • Proposals Rejected: [Count]
  • Proposals Conditional: [Count]
  • Proposals Pending: [Count]

Review Performance

  • Average Review Time: [Days]
  • On-Time Review Rate: [Percentage]
  • Fastest Review: [Days]
  • Slowest Review: [Days]

Implementation

  • Proposals Implemented: [Count]
  • Average Implementation Time: [Days]
  • Implementation Success Rate: [Percentage]

Process Health

  • Compliance Violations: [Count] (Target: 0)
  • Emergency Changes: [Count]
  • Process Exceptions: [Count]
  • ICCC Disputes: [Count]

Data Collection Methods

Automated Collection

  • Set up automated tracking (if tools available)
  • Extract data from proposal files
  • Track dates automatically
  • Generate reports automatically

Manual Collection

  • Regular manual data entry
  • Quarterly metrics compilation
  • Review and validation
  • Documentation updates

Hybrid Approach

  • Use tools for basic tracking
  • Manual verification and analysis
  • Regular review and updates

Reporting Schedule

Monthly

  • Quick status update
  • Active proposals count
  • Pending recognition status

Quarterly

  • Comprehensive metrics report
  • Trend analysis
  • Process health assessment
  • Recommendations for improvement

Annually

  • Full year review
  • Long-term trends
  • Framework effectiveness assessment
  • Major process improvements

Metrics Tracking Template

Individual Proposal Tracking

Proposal ID: PROPOSAL-YYYY-MMDD-NNN Title: [Title]

Metric Value Date
Submission Date YYYY-MM-DD -
DBIS Recognition Date YYYY-MM-DD -
ICCC Recognition Date YYYY-MM-DD -
SMOM/SMOA Recognition Date YYYY-MM-DD -
Approval Date YYYY-MM-DD -
Review Time (Days) [Days] -
Implementation Start YYYY-MM-DD -
Implementation Complete YYYY-MM-DD -
Implementation Time (Days) [Days] -
Status [Status] -

Analysis and Insights

Trend Analysis

Track over time:

  • Proposal submission trends
  • Review time trends
  • Approval rate trends
  • Implementation success trends

Pattern Recognition

Identify:

  • Common rejection reasons
  • Typical review bottlenecks
  • Implementation challenges
  • Process improvement opportunities

Benchmarking

Compare:

  • Current vs. previous periods
  • Actual vs. target metrics
  • Process effectiveness over time

Action Items from Metrics

Based on metrics, identify:

  1. Process Improvements

    • Areas needing optimization
    • Bottleneck reduction
    • Timeline adjustments

  2. Training Needs

    • Common proposal issues
    • Review process improvements
    • Compliance education

  3. Policy Updates

    • Process refinements
    • Timeline adjustments
    • Procedure clarifications

Metrics Storage

Recommended Location

  • metrics/governance-metrics-YYYY-Q[1-4].md - Quarterly reports
  • metrics/governance-metrics-YYYY.md - Annual summary
  • Spreadsheet/database (if using tracking tools)

Retention

  • Quarterly reports: Retain indefinitely
  • Individual proposal data: Retain with proposal
  • Aggregate data: Retain for trend analysis

Template Version: 1.0 Last Updated: 2025-01-27 Review Frequency: Quarterly

Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink